Looking for a Muslim Pro Alternative? What a Private Prayer App Should Do

If you've found yourself searching for a Muslim Pro alternative, you're almost certainly not looking for a different shade of green or a new font. You're looking for the same essentials — accurate prayer times, a Qibla, a tracker — without the two things that have driven so many Muslims to look elsewhere: the ads, and the unease about where your data is going.

That unease is well-founded, and it's worth understanding clearly before you choose a replacement. Because the goal isn't just to swap one app for another that looks nicer; it's to land on a prayer app you can actually trust with the most sensitive information you own. This guide explains what happened, what to look for instead, and how to evaluate any alternative honestly.

Why People Are Looking to Switch

Two reasons come up again and again, and they're connected.

The first is ads. A free prayer app that runs ads has to make money somehow, and ads inside an act of worship sit badly with a lot of people — a flashing banner between you and the Qibla is a strange thing to accept. But ads are also a symptom of a deeper issue, because targeted advertising runs on data.

The second, more serious reason is privacy. Prayer apps hold extraordinarily sensitive information: they know your religion, they know your location five times a day, they know the rhythm of your life. And some of the biggest names mishandled exactly that.

Muslim Pro became the centre of a major controversy when it emerged that a data broker, X-Mode, had obtained location data from its users — data that was reportedly sold onward, including to US military contractors. Separately, the app Salaat First was found to be recording and selling users' precise location information — latitude, longitude, device details, timestamps — to a broker with ties to government agencies. These weren't obscure apps. They were among the most-installed prayer apps in the world, trusted by millions who never imagined their worship was being turned into a commodity.

Whatever the specifics and whatever has changed since, the episode shifted how a lot of Muslims think. The question stopped being "which prayer app is prettiest?" and became "which prayer app can I trust?"

What "Private" Should Actually Mean

The word "private" gets sprinkled on app store listings the way "natural" gets sprinkled on food labels. To cut through it, hold any alternative to a few concrete tests rather than vibes:

• Your data stays on your device. Your prayer logs, streaks, and history should live on your phone — not on the company's servers where they can be analysed, breached, or sold. If your tracking syncs to a cloud account by default, ask why.
• Location leaves only to fetch prayer times. Calculating accurate times needs your approximate coordinates, and that's a fair trade. What's not fair is that location being shared with advertisers or brokers. The honest version: coordinates go to the prayer-times service and nowhere else.
• No ads, no third-party trackers. No ad networks means no advertising SDKs quietly collecting data in the background. An app with zero ads has far less reason to track you in the first place.
• A business model you can see. If you can't tell how a free app makes money, that is the answer — and it's usually your data. An app with an honest, optional paid tier has aligned its incentives with serving you.

We unpack the ethics of all this further in our piece on privacy and ethics in Islamic apps.

The Landscape of Alternatives

The good news is that the privacy backlash produced a whole wave of apps built specifically to be trustworthy. Without ranking them, it's worth knowing the categories you'll find:

• Privacy-first all-rounders. Apps created in direct response to the Muslim Pro controversy, built around the promise that your data doesn't leave your phone, usually ad-free and funded by an optional subscription or donations.
• Open-source options. For the technically inclined, open-source prayer apps let anyone inspect the code to verify there's no hidden tracking — the strongest possible privacy guarantee, though often with a more utilitarian design.
• Focused tools. Rather than one app trying to be everything, some do one thing exceptionally — a beautiful tracker, a serious habit-builder, or a prayer-focus app that locks distractions until you pray.

Where Deeny fits: it's a private, ad-free prayer companion built on exactly the principles above. Your tracking, streaks, and Screen Time data stay on your device; only your approximate coordinates leave, solely to calculate accurate prayer times; and there are no ads and nothing sold. On top of the essentials, it adds the accountability layer the big apps don't — a Fajr alarm and a Salah Focus mode that gently locks distracting apps from each adhan until you confirm you've prayed.

How to Switch Without Friction

Moving to a new prayer app is easier than it feels. A short checklist:

1. Confirm the times match. Set your new app to the same calculation method you trusted before, and check a couple of days against your old source so the transition is seamless.
2. Re-grant only what's needed. Location for prayer times, notifications for reminders. Be wary of any prayer app asking for contacts, photos, or anything unrelated.
3. Read the new privacy policy — actually read it. Search it for "advertising," "third party," and "sell." Two minutes here is worth more than any review.
4. Carry over your qada count. If you were tracking missed prayers to make up, move that number over so you don't lose your place.
5. Give it a week. Any new tool feels unfamiliar for a few days. Judge it on day seven, not day one.

For a thorough, app-agnostic version, see our checklist for choosing the right prayer app.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Muslim Pro safe to use?

Muslim Pro was at the centre of a 2020 controversy in which a data broker obtained and reportedly sold its users' location data. The company has stated it has since changed its practices. Whether you're comfortable with it is a personal call — but the episode is why many Muslims now prefer apps that keep data on the device with no ads.

What is the best private alternative to Muslim Pro?

There's no single answer, but the best private alternatives share the same traits: data kept on your device, location used only for prayer times, no ads, no third-party trackers, and a transparent business model. Privacy-first apps and open-source options both fit; Deeny is one built specifically around these principles.

Are free prayer apps selling my data?

Not all of them, but "free" apps with ads have a financial reason to collect and monetise data, and several major ones have been caught doing exactly that. If you can't see how a free app makes money, assume your data is part of the answer, and prefer an ad-free app with a clear paid tier or donation model.

Do private prayer apps still give accurate prayer times?

Yes. Calculating accurate times only requires your approximate location, which a private app sends to a prayer-times service and nowhere else. You keep full accuracy and your choice of calculation method without giving up your privacy.

---

Switching away from a big-name prayer app isn't about chasing a trend — it's about refusing to let your worship become someone else's data. The essentials haven't changed: accurate times, a Qibla, a way to stay consistent. What can change is whether you get them from a tool that respects the sacredness of what it's helping you do. Choose the app whose answer to "where does my data go?" is, simply, "nowhere it shouldn't."